Markup Isn’t Margin (and the Day-and-a-Half Job That Took Three)

By John Dudley, 30-year general contractor and co-host of Around the House
The day-and-a-half job
Here’s a story that shows up on contractor forums all the time, in one version or another.
A guy prices a small job. Materials come to $650. He figures a day and a half of work and quotes $1,400. The customer says yes. Good day.
The job takes three days.
When it’s over he says what a lot of us have said at least once: I’m not sure I made anything.
He’s probably right. Run it:
- $1,400 minus $650 in materials leaves $750.
- At a day and a half, that’s $500 a day for his labor, his truck, his insurance and his profit.
- At three days, it’s $250 a day. For all of it.
Nothing went “wrong” on that job. No disaster, no lawsuit. The price was set before he knew his number, and the job quietly ate the difference.
The arithmetic: 30% on top isn’t 30%
Most small contractors price the same way: add up the cost, put a percent on top. That percent is the markup.
What you keep, as a share of what the customer pays, is the margin. They are not the same number, and the gap gets bigger the higher you go.
Take a $10,000 cost and put 30% on top:
- Cost: $10,000
- Markup, 30% of cost: $3,000
- Price: $13,000
- What you kept, as a share of the price: $3,000 ÷ $13,000 = 23%
You said 30. You kept 23. And that 23 is before anything goes sideways.
The quick table:
| Put this on top of cost | You keep this much of the price |
|---|---|
| 20% | about 16.7% |
| 25% | 20% |
| 30% | about 23% |
| 50% | about 33% |
| 100% | 50% |
If you want to keep 20% of the price, you have to mark up 25%. If you’ve been marking up 20% and calling it “20% profit,” you’ve been keeping about 16.7 and paying for everything else out of that.
What eats the rest
That 23% still has to cover a lot before any of it is profit. Three things eat it on almost every small job.
1. The days you didn’t count. The day-and-a-half job that took three. Drive time, the supply-house run, waiting on the inspector, the afternoon lost to rain, the punch list. If your labor number is “how long the work takes when it goes right,” every job that goes normal costs you money.
2. Material you bought by the stick but billed by the foot. You need 397 feet of copper. The supply house sells it in 10-foot sticks. You buy 40 sticks, 400 feet, and the scrap is yours. Same with sheets of drywall, boxes of shingles, bundles of anything. If your estimate says 397 feet and your receipt says 40 sticks, the difference came out of your margin.
3. The line nobody bills for. The truck. Insurance. Tools. The phone, the software, the bookkeeping. And callbacks: the trip back to fix the thing that wasn’t your fault but you fixed anyway. None of that shows up on a single job’s materials list, and all of it gets paid from what’s left over.
Add those up and you can see how a “30% job” turns into a job you’re not sure you made anything on.
The habit: know the number before you start
You don’t fix this with a bigger percent. You fix it with an order of operations.
- Price from your real cost. What the materials actually cost you, in the quantities you actually have to buy. What the labor actually costs, for the days it actually takes, travel included.
- Put your markup on top, and know what it keeps. If you need to keep 20%, mark up 25%. Use the table.
- Know the number before you start. If the job only works when everything goes right, it doesn’t work. Find that out at the kitchen table, not on day three.
The guy with the day-and-a-half job wasn’t bad at his trade. He priced the job before he knew what it cost him. That’s a habit, and habits can change on the next bid.
Where InstaBid fits
The material and price side of step one is where InstaBid comes in.
It starts every estimate from real, regionally adjusted cost: 25,533 prices, adjusted across 51 states. It buys by the unit, so 397 feet of copper bills as 40 sticks. Your markup, tax and deposit percent sit on top, and you can change every one of them. When you save your own price for something, your price wins, every time.
You still set the markup. You still know your truck and your insurance better than anybody. InstaBid gets you a real cost to put it on.
Deja de perder trabajos por presupuestos lentos.
Tu cliente pregunta, InstaBid arma el presupuesto, tú apruebas con un toque. Pruébalo: 10 días gratis, sin tarjeta de crédito.
Empieza gratis →